Looking for a critique of your site?

We now have a central place within our community for members to put their work up for critique. I think it will help everyone if we take any critique requests for our sites and place it in the Critique Forum. That way we have clear rules for critiques.

We'll reserve this space for the rest of our web geekery

doh paid members only... *sigh*

Post it here in the web forum esh, we'd love to take a look!

Originally Posted by Brad Daily

Post it here in the web forum esh, we'd love to take a look!

Cool thanks, don't want to break the rules :-p

There really should be another plan offered other than the $29.95...
I would be willing to donate say $5/year that gives access to just the basic board features such as the other forums & private messaging. I don't have a need for all of the media content/live chat/magazine/etc...

my $0.02

Originally Posted by Brad Daily

We now have a central place within our community for members to put their work up for critique. I think it will help everyone if we take any critique requests for our sites and place it in the Critique Forum. That way we have clear rules for critiques.

We'll reserve this space for the rest of our web geekery

Hi Brad,
I thought your critique idea was good, but now I'm not sure what to think. I posted a video up on the forum and asked for feedback. I haven't gotten any, so I'm not sure what to think. Maybe is't so bad that no one can put into words anything that would help...or maybe ... well, I can't imagine what to do to encourage response. Can you help?
http://www.churchmedia.net/showthread.php?t=7735
Christian Aftercare Ministries
thanks.

Originally Posted by rkirkhart

I can't imagine what to do to encourage response. Can you help?
http://www.churchmedia.net/showthread.php?t=7735
Christian Aftercare Ministries
thanks.

Oaky, I responded with critique - I didn't before because you honestly posted it was 11 minutes long and I didn't have 11 minutes at the time I first saw the post.

Originally Posted by MediaBLITZ

Oaky, I responded with critique - I didn't before because you honestly posted it was 11 minutes long and I didn't have 11 minutes at the time I first saw the post.

duh, that makes sense. Probably a lot of us consider the time when we look at stuff. One piece of feed back I didn't think about. I'll go check the comments. thanks!

[JMac]

I would love to post some stuff on this forum but I am not a Pro Member.

[[Admin] danroth]

Let me just put in a plug for pro membership..
at $30/yr it's a steal!

It's worth it just to support the website, even if you don't use the MXC.
If you do use the MXC, it's just worth that much more.

By the way, I just wanted everyone to know that I got a great private review of my video that was very helpful. Some will give public critiques, some private. All are welcome. This is a good place to learn among friends.

I just finished a big redesign of www.westwinds.org and would love any feedback. Im new to the community and i totaly love it! i think i will have to get the pro membership when i get the money.
thanks,
-davey

[pastorn8]

I just finished reworking our site as well www.gracechristianonline.org (well, mostly finished--I've got a couple things to fill in yet). I'm a newb when it comes to this, so any critiques/advice is welcome.

Thanks!