A few random thoughts:
1 -- I didn't see a single person on the site. Lots of great graphics, but no smiling faces. Feels kind of cold.
2 --Why isn't any of your Twitter info on the "contact us" page?
3 -- Does the church not have a Facebook Page or Google+ Page?
4 -- Embed a real Google Map on the "when and where" page instead of a screenshot; much easier for us Android folks to star it and have it handy in the car.
5 -- I have no idea what to expect from your worship service. Traditional? More contemporary? Should I wear a suit or jeans?
(I just found the answer, but it was tucked away under the very subtle "?" icon in the corner)
Hope that helps.
My site, focused on church marketing, SEO and stuff like that --> mickmel.com